Survey results
At the end of the workshop we asked the participants to fill in surveys asking what they liked most and what they had reservations about. Below are the respondents’ opinions, collected and organized.
Over a hundred respondents answered our request to rate the Advent workshop of liturgical singing. The average rating given by participants on a scale from 1 (“I have serious reservations about the course and/or content of the workshop; I expected something completely different”) to 5 (“it fully met my expectations; I rate its course and content very highly”) was 4.35 – slightly more than “I rate the course and content of the workshop highly, but it differed slightly from my expectations”.
The choir conductors received very high marks for their professionalism and competence, as well as for the way they led the classes, their commitment, openness and ability to convey the depth of the songs. Some, however, complained about the lack of a warm-up before group work and of breaks during rehearsals, and about too little theoretical information and too few exercises that schola leaders could use in their own practice.
The chant group also rated the competence of their instructor highly, and although some pointed out that he talked too much, others were grateful to be able to draw from the true goldmine of knowledge about chant that Mr. Marcin turned out to be.
Working in small choirs was also appreciated, and the sectional rehearsals helped people learn the material. Some felt, however, that there were too many songs and too little time to learn them all well enough. It was also noted that work in the large choir was made harder by having too many singers in it.
The participants liked the repertoire we proposed. They also valued the chance to learn how to interpret the pieces.
The answers also showed that the prayer side of the workshop was a very important aspect. Participants liked being able to take part in the Rorate Mass, the Liturgy of the Hours and adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. The talks on the Eucharist given by Fr. Tomasz Kwiecień OP were also rated highly. Some, though, wanted even more and suggested giving the workshop more of a retreat character.
Some rated the Saturday vigil as beautiful and praiseworthy, while others had reservations. These concerned, for example, the awkward placing of the choir, which made it hard for some singers to see the conductor. Participants in the polyphonic singing classes regretted that they had not been introduced to the principles of performing monodic chant, which made it very hard for them to join in the Gregorian singing during the Office of Readings. There was also criticism of the form of the vigil: according to some it did not allow for recollection in prayer. Someone even accused us of liturgical incorrectness.
People also complained about the low temperature in the basilica and too much light during the vigil (especially during the Office of Readings).
Of the Sunday thematic group classes, the voice production exercises led by Mr. Jacek Sykulski received the most applause.
The meeting with Mr. Grzegorz Juras, who focused on diction, also had a strong echo, but here many opinions were critical. The main criticism was the lack of practical exercises through which participants could improve their articulation. They were also disappointed that the time for these classes was limited to just 30 minutes.
Opinions on the organization were divided. People criticized the overloaded programme, which tired participants out, the late finish of the classes and too little time for rest, the lack of planning for free time (for example, shared lunches) and a lack of punctuality.
Many said that the workshop was too short. We were also told that information about costs was not clear, and it was suggested that a fixed participation fee be set in advance. It was also suggested that the sheet music be available on the website before the workshop began.
There were also complaints about conditions in some of the accommodation, where the rooms were said to be cold. The same was said of the rehearsal rooms. This last complaint surprised us, as the heating was on in all the rooms.
Yet a great many participants praised the organization, including the quality (also aesthetic) and availability of the materials, the good planning of the workshop, the intensity of the work, the shared breakfasts, the clear signs to the rooms and the care for participants. They also stressed the relaxed, warm atmosphere and the conditions conducive to prayer.
Among the suggestions for the future, the most prominent were setting a fixed participation fee, dividing participants into more and less advanced groups, and the possibility of working with several conductors.
To sum up, let us add that participants liked the very idea of organizing the workshop. They were also pleased with the commitment on both sides and the results of our work together – and that is exactly what we wanted! They also told us they are looking forward to the next one – and so are we.
Survey preparation and analysis: Katarzyna Starzyk.
Text: Tomasz Grabowski OP.